As a former western fencer this topic reminds me of what was called second intention.
In On Fencing, Aldo Nadi discussed second intention as a sophisticated tactical concept in foil fencing, emphasizing its role in outsmarting an opponent through deliberate planning and deception. Second intention involves executing an initial action (e.g., a feint or false attack) to provoke a predictable response from the opponent, setting them up for a subsequent, decisive action that scores the touch. Nadi described it as a strategic maneuver requiring precise timing, control, and an understanding of the opponent’s reactions.
He explained that second intention is distinct from simpler attacks because it relies on manipulating the opponent’s defense or counterattack. For example, a fencer might initiate a feint to draw a parry, then exploit the opponent’s commitment to that parry with a secondary action, such as a disengage or counterattack. Nadi stressed the importance of mental alertness and tactical foresight
Thank you very much for the inspiring talk and sharing experience!
As a former western fencer this topic reminds me of what was called second intention.
In On Fencing, Aldo Nadi discussed second intention as a sophisticated tactical concept in foil fencing, emphasizing its role in outsmarting an opponent through deliberate planning and deception. Second intention involves executing an initial action (e.g., a feint or false attack) to provoke a predictable response from the opponent, setting them up for a subsequent, decisive action that scores the touch. Nadi described it as a strategic maneuver requiring precise timing, control, and an understanding of the opponent’s reactions.
He explained that second intention is distinct from simpler attacks because it relies on manipulating the opponent’s defense or counterattack. For example, a fencer might initiate a feint to draw a parry, then exploit the opponent’s commitment to that parry with a secondary action, such as a disengage or counterattack. Nadi stressed the importance of mental alertness and tactical foresight
Another interesting topic well explained! You know a video is good when you think about it’s contents afterwards!
Might the slight ‘offering of the head’ as a target at the beginning of Iai’s Tsukekomi/Gyakuto be considered a resolute dropping of kyo into jitsu?